Default HubSpot Blog

TMS Customized Freight Tendering Features

[fa icon="calendar"] Aug 8, 2018 10:41:01 AM / by John Rediehs

Transportation management systems in the market are not very flexible when it comes to managing the tendering of freight to transportation vendors. They work in a assembly line system and only allow tenders based on a single type of information or factor. The system is not able to treat different load types based on region, equipment, date or urgency from the tender process that has been set up and been defaulted for the entire system.

This lack of flexibility does not allow for the TMS users to benefit from the diversity of their freight. If you have ever worked in a shipping company, a brokerage or trucking company you are aware that all freight is not the equal and therefore should not be treated the same.

Your TMS should have the ability to tender freight by different criteria and these setups should be able to follow rules to rotate based on smart criteria. The system should know when to tender based of contract price, when to submit spot quotes, when to introduce a load to the bidding process and when not to submit to the bidding process. What loads are urgent and not urgent what destination are in peak season?

What are the different factors that make freight more valuable than other type of freight and what are shippers leaving on the table by using a single form of tendering?

For example:

You have a lane from Chicago, IL going to Miami, FL every Tuesday and Thursday fifty-two weeks a year. Every year you bid out the lane to 50 carriers. You have 10 vendors who always come back at $2.25 cents a mile. And then you have carrier B come in at 2.65/Mile as the next cheapest option.

To manage the lane you are using a price tiered tendering system. So every time the order is built it automatically starts going down the list, the first 10 carriers do not accept the load and carrier B ends up taking the load. Carrier B takes 90% of the freight each year. The first 10 carriers have a low price but no capacity and really have nothing to offer you 10 months out of the year.

Then produce season in Florida occurs and all of a sudden that lane just became more valuable. So if you are on a price tiered tendering process Carrier B will not even see the freight because the first 10 carriers will almost always accept the freight during produce season.

Leaving carrier B in the dust during the time they need the freight the most and allowing the first 10 carriers who do not support the company 10 months out of the year to take the freight at a higher than normal produce market price, because of the contract pricing. The single entity tendering process is so rigid the shipper will end up paying less than the usual carrier but more than what spot is. The regular carrier will be left looking for freight for those two months and in all probability taking that same lane for less than the price you are getting from your lowest cost option.

So how would custom freight tendering options solve this problem?

There are several ways in which you can solve the problem with custom freight tendering:

1. Set up an auto switch within your system for all Reefer freight going to FL for April and May to go out for a bid first and then if the reserve price is not met to tender on price with you established vendors.

Outcome: Gives your high volume vendors the opportunity to compete for the load in all seasons and does not reward low price carriers who have no intention of moving anything outside of produce season. Also may lower your overall price by 10 or 15% from your already lowest cost option.

2. Set up a match price option tendering system --- which will tender to high volume vendors for that lane first, for the months of April and May and give them the option to match the low cost vendor, if vendors do not match after 30 minutes continue with price tier tendering

Outcome: Gives the high volume service providers the option to match low cost pricing to keep the freight during produce season and allows your company to capitalize on savings

3. Re-Quote all FL lanes for the 2 month period, the system will automatically run a check on all of the lanes that are running to FL and will then identify which lanes need to be re-quoted based on the % difference of market price and the lowest cost options in the system.

Outcome: A completely different price structure for the 2 month period to capitalize a maximum savings for the shipper and an opportunity for all of the vendors to participate in the lane when the freight has a higher value to vendors.

4. Set up a default % of shipments that will always go to the highest volume vendor for the lane.

Outcome: Carrier B will always get a certain % of loads even in produce season. The shipper is able to realize a certain amount of saving while keeping Carrier B involved in the lane.

The amount of scenarios that could be built here is almost mind boggling but if you are not actively benefiting from your freight in the marketplace you could be leaving as much as 15-30% of freight cost on the table.

Your TMS should have the ability to tender freight by different criteria and these setups should be able to follow rules to rotate based on smart criteria. The system should know when to tender based of contract price, when to submit spot quotes, when to introduce a load to the bidding process and when not to submit to the bidding process.

When is the last time that a TMS suggested to actively rebid a lane mid-year?

Maybe you want to build a process flow that incorporates all 3 variable mentioned above but you want to change the order in which they take place to capture the best market rates or go with your contracted pricing. Companies are always paying for peak season pricing why not benefit from this knowledge.

Does your system have the ability to designate time sensitive vs non time sensitive?

Can you change model of distribution by client?

One size does not fit all. Why should you settle for a simple tendering platform?

Supercharge your savings, customer service and carrier loyalty with a smart tendering system.

Topics: TMS, Smart Freight Tendering, Transportation Management

John Rediehs

Written by John Rediehs